3.5.0: anton piller injunction. types of injunction and its enforcement. Other factors considered by the courts are the futility of granting an injunction and the possibility of compliance with the order. Olasupo Shasore By the very nature of the case the trial would entail essentially a comparison of the two marks within the provisions of the Trade Marks Act and can be completed in a few days. The factors considered by the courts in determining whether or not to grant an injunction will depend on the type of injunction that is being sought. Naturally, the respondent contested the application, arguing that the court lacked jurisdiction or power to make the order owing to the agreement to arbitrate between the parties. Nigerian courts have been known to issue anti-suit injunctions by courts to restrain the commencement or progress of a court action in a foreign or local jurisdiction. july 1, 2018. chapter 4 examining other forms of injunction and the power of the For instance, the court may order the demolition of a house. It is a civil, search and seizure order that is most commonly used in cases of intellectual property rights. The plaintiff may come to court seeking an injunction to stop the development of the property. 3.2.0: interlocutory injunction. Tele/+234 806 819 1709 It is anticipatory; at the time of the injunction, no actual injury to the plaintiff’s legal right has occurred. 3.4.0: mareva injunction. Although the courts have this discretion as to whether or not an injunction is granted, they are guided by certain principles, and will consider several factors before granting one. These are situations where you may ask the offending party to stop doing something that is bothersome and a nuisance to you. In 1980, the injunction was granted against a non-resident present in England, and subsequently, in a different case, the jurisdiction was extended to a resident defendant. Injunctions in brief Perpetual injunction – . 3.8.0: enforcement of orders of injunction. Secondly, the legal right must have been infringed or there is a probability that it will be infringed. A copyright is infringed by any person who without the license or authorization of the owner of the copyright uses or causes the copyrighted work to be used. EXCESS OF INJUNCTION IN NIGERIA JUDICIAL SYSTEM ABSTRACT Injunction serves as an order of equitable nature restraining the person to whom it is directed from performing a specified act or in certain exceptional circumstances cases requiring him to perform a specified act. So can the plaintiff simply say that since a Mareva injunction is an injunction, it automatically falls within O 11 r 1(b)? Plaintiff cannot use force to enter premises but the defendant will be in contempt of court if s/he denies admission and, in addition, the court may draw adverse inferences from such a refusal (i.e., it does not look good for the credibility of the defendant). The work further examines the need for the Nigerian court to grant injunctions in matters of extreme urgency and the power of the court in granting injunction. EX-PARTE INJUNCTION In the annals of Anglo-Nigeria common law, certain principles are fundamental. In all, the courts are trying to serve justice to the parties in the dispute. A copyright holder whose right has been infringed is entitled to damages or injunctions. Injunctions may include confidentiality restrictions to prevent disclosure of the detail of the injunction, particularly where they have been obtained without notice to the respondent (see below). Covid-19-related disputes in the financial services sector – a transatlantic perspective from Jeremy Sher, Sam Bodle, Isabelle Ord, Margo Tank and Adam Dubin of DLA Piper. What happens if a baseball stadium is built next to your house, and lights shine in on you every night preventing you from sleeping? Anti-Arbitration Injunction in Nigeria. The work further examines the need for the Nigerian court to grant injunctions in matters of extreme urgency and the power of the court in granting injunction. Because the essence of the injunction is surprise, it is normally sought on an ex parte basis (and the defendant may subsequently apply to have the injunction discharged or varied). Increasingly, more international arbitrations are being seated in Nigeria; the recent amendments to the Arbitration Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce – such as Article 29, which provides for interim measures requested prior to the constitution of an arbitral tribunal – are important developments for the country’s community. Injunctions are equitable remedies that are given at the discretion of the court. However, it was not uncommon for a party to an arbitral proceeding to approach a court for an injunction to restrain further proceedings in arbitration, a wholly undesirable practice. 3.1.0: ex-parte injunction. Established in 1963 and became effective on October 1, 1963, prior to the enunciation of the Federal Republic of Nigeria and the 1960 Constitution. Federal Republic of Nigeria Official Gazette No. Interim injunction; The Supreme Court of Nigeria in the case of Kotoye v Central Bank of Nigeria (1989) 1 NWLR (pt. The cost of registering an NGO or charitable foundation in Nigeria will be differed on a case by case basis and the roles of any lawyers assisting to incorporate such organization would take in completing the entire process. However, there are a number of guiding principles that guide the courts in granting any injunction. The respondent had monies in its accounts in several banks. The order may simply be that the balance in the account must not fall below a certain figure. Prohibitory injunction – prohibitory injunctions are orders to refrain from or stop doing a wrongful act. These orders are granted while the primary action is pending. This approach should, of course, be commended. These orders affect arbitration where the party seeking the injunction does so to protect arbitral proceedings in Nigeria. Media gag orders are a popular type of injunction usually meant to prohibit the media from reporting on a high profile trial until the trial’s conclusion. A temporary injunction or preliminary injunction is a provisional remedy granted to restrain activity on a temporary basis until the court can make a final decision after trial. ICLG.com > Commercial Dispute Resolution > Nigeria: injunctions and protective orders, Published by: There are majorly four different types of the election in Nigeria. If the order would be too oppressive to the defendant, the courts will refuse to grant the order. Arbitration continues to enjoy increasing patronage in Nigerian commercial disputes. The team comprises professionals and Consultants from different fields of human endeavour. The court’s jurisdiction to grant injunctions, as well as its ability to effectively enforce them through committal proceedings, is dependent on proper service of defendants/respondents. An interim injunction to restrain the defendants and the represented class from selling the offending product until the determination of the motion on notice filed at the same time as the motion ex-parte. Also, the work further examines the various types of injunction applicable in the Nigerian judicial system. Legislation allows parties to approach court for interim measures, and such requests shall not be deemed to be incompatible or a waiver of the agreement to arbitrate. Types of injunctions obtainable in court are; An Interim injunction-although lasts for a short time, is usually granted only in cases of urgency requiring immediate relief. The loan was secured by Mr Patrick’s landed property located in Lagos. It is designed to examine the various types of injunction available in Nigeria and the purpose they serve. The sources of the jurisdiction and power to grant orders in aid of arbitration include national legislation, case law and the rules governing arbitration – both institutional and ad hoc. Basically, the order aims to prevent a situation where before or after judgment, a defendant quickly transfers their assets out of the jurisdiction to avoid the judgment or penalty awarded by the courts. The purpose is to assess the usefulness of the remedy in justice administration in Nigeria. In the former case it is called a restrictive and prohibitory injunction and in the latter a mandatory or positive injunction. There are several means of identification for Nigerians like the international passport, voter’s card, or driver’s license. The work further examines the need for the Nigerian court to grant injunctions in matters of extreme urgency and the power of the court in granting injunction. It also considers the procedure by which the Nigerian courts grant the application of any type of injunction as well as the grounds that are sine qua non before the application of injunction is granted by the Nigerian courts. If the defendant has nothing to hide, they should have no hesitation complying with the order. What now seems to be an equally vital terrain to protect is the right to arbitrate, either by restraining the breach of the agreement to arbitrate or protecting – albeit sometimes on an interim basis – the rights of parties during the dispute. As seen above, arbitral tribunals may make orders and may direct a party to take such interim measure of protection as the tribunal may consider necessary. 1.2 Background to the Study The work further examines the need for the Nigerian court to grant injunctions in matters of extreme urgency and the power of the court in granting injunction. It is important to note that with interlocutory injunctions, the plaintiff will normally be asked for an undertaking as to damages which is held by the court for the benefit of the defendant, if it is determined at the trial that the injunction should not have been obtained. Many African jurisdictions are now supportive of arbitration; recent developments show that Nigeria and Lagos have, in many respects, led in seeking to bolster certainty and effectiveness of the arbitral process. A mandatory injunction is a court order compelling a person to perform a certain act. It is designed to examine the various types of injunction available in Nigeria and the purpose they serve. Anti-suit orders & injunctions. Injunction; Injunction is a court order that coerces the defendant to take specific acts or refrains him or her from engaging in certain actions, i.e., breaching a contract. Ordinarily, the principle is that courts are not allowed to intervene in an arbitration matter; this position is enshrined in section 34 Arbitration and Conciliation Act (ACA) 4: "a Court shall not intervene in any matter governed by this Act except where so … It is usually sought by a claimant in an arbitral proceeding where it appears that by the conduct of the respondent or its privies, the respondent may not be able to satisfy any award that may be made in the matter. TYPES OF ELECTION IN NIGERIA . The work further examines the need for the Nigerian court to grant injunctions in matters of extreme urgency and the power of the court in granting injunction. It may also be made to ensure the discontinuance of such an action, particularly where the suit is likely to cause imminent harm, prejudice the subject matter of the dispute or jeopardise the arbitral process. Types of Injunction. Preliminary A preliminary or temporary injunction is a provisional remedy that is invoked to preserve the subject matter in its existing condition. The note considers interim and final injunctions, prohibitory and mandatory injunctions, quia timet and springboard injunctions and injunctions in support of arbitration proceedings. It is the final order of the court after the resolution of a dispute. Valeria Butyrina and Ekaterina Bubnova of the Russian Arbitration Center consider whether an arbitrator’s duty to disclose information potentially leading to a conflict of interest outweighs the confidentiality obligations with reference to the IBA guidelines, arbitration rules and case law. Mareva or Freezing Injunction V. Security for Costs in Support of Foreign Proceedings VI. A permanent injunction is a final order and is usually only granted after a trial. Anti-Suit Injunction III. n. a writ (order) issued by a court ordering someone to do something or prohibiting some act after a court hearing. Interlocutory injunction – an interlocutory injunction is a temporary order to maintain the status quo until the main issue (primary legal action) is resolved or until enough time passes to determine the effect of the order. E-mail: thenigerialawyers@gmail.com, thenigerialawyers@gmail.com, editor@thenigerialawyer.com, Meningitis: NMA faults Yari over cause of meningitis, Osinbajo, Malami, Magu, DSS move to save anti-graft war. Seplat had appealed the December 24, 2020 decision of the Federal High Court granting injunctions that, among others, resulted in … EXCESS OF INJUNCTION IN NIGERIA JUDICIAL SYSTEM ABSTRACT Injunction serves as an order of equitable nature restraining the person to whom it is directed from performing a specified act or in certain exceptional circumstances cases requiring him to perform a specified act. A discretionary remedy that takes the form of a court order requiring a party to either refrain from doing something (prohibitory injunction) or to specifically do something (mandatory injunction). 3.6.0: perpetual injunction. Suits in Nigeria have been the target of such orders, such as in Travelport Global Distribution Systems BV v Bellview Airlines Ltd 2012 WL 39258556 (SDNY Sept 10 2012). Select Currency excess of injunction in nigeria judicial system,law project topics and materials,excess of injunction in nigeria judicial system Types of Injunction Mareva Injunctions This is used in extreme cases to freeze the assets of a defendant. It also considers the procedure by which the Nigerian courts grant the application of any type of injunction as well as the grounds that are sine qua non before the application of injunction is granted by the … These injunction are as follows: ranging from ex-parte, interim, interlocutory, perpetual, mandatory, mareva to anton piller injunction. The most common types of injunctions are temporary, preventive, permanent, and mandatory. Types of Injunction Mareva Injunctions This is used in extreme cases to freeze the assets of a defendant. Under Nigerian Law, the court tribunal may also take such interim measures of protection as may be necessary in respect of the subject matter of the dispute, before the commencement of arbitral proceedings. The English Court of Chancery was a court of “equity” rather than “law,” so its remedies were known as equitable remedies.. Conclusion 21. An injunctionis an order by the court to a party to do or refrain from doing a particularact to ensure that justice is done. It is usually necessary to prove high likelihood of irreparable harm in the absence of a preliminary injunction before such an injunction may be granted; otherwise the party may have to wait for trial to … Anti-suit orders & injunctions Nigerian courts have been known to issue anti-suit injunctions by courts to restrain the commencement or progress of a court action in a foreign or local jurisdiction. However, in terms of case law in Nigeria, recognition of Mareva injunction may be first traced to the Supreme Court case of SOTIMINU V. OCEAN STEAMSHIP (NIG) LTD (1992) 5 NWLR (PT.239) 1, where the Supreme Court acknowledged as a preventive measure, the power of the court to grant anticipatory and preservative ex parte injunction to a Plaintiff with a good prima facie … Thirdly, the injunction will only be granted if there is no other remedy available or adequate in the circumstance. Such interim measures may include a direction that parties maintain status quo pending the delivery of a final award on the dispute, preserve the subject matter of the dispute and provide a means of preserving the assets out of which a subsequent award may be satisfied. Sometimes it could be used for the illegal constructionwork, which is harm for other or developer start work in another person’s land.It could be intellectual property rather than land i.e. As trends continue to show that courts will “not be over ready to set aside awards where the parties have agreed to abide the decision of a tribunal of their own selection,” the current advancement of commercial arbitration in Africa’s busiest jurisdiction should be encouraged. It also considers the procedure by which the Nigerian courts grant the application of any type of injunction as well as the grounds that are sine qua non before the application of injunction is granted by the Nigerian courts. Tribunals seated in Nigeria ought not to grant such requests. Persons Exempted from National Identification Number (NIN) Registration. A Mareva injunction is usually granted before the plaintiff obtains judgment in the primary legal action but it is also possible to obtain a post-judgment Mareva to prevent the defendant from thwarting the plaintiff’s attempts to execute a judgment. Injunctions are judicial remedy by which a person is ordered to refrain from doing or to do a particular act or thing. injunction. Its purpose is to prevent dis-solution of the plaintiff's rights. The purpose is to assess the usefulness of the remedy in justice administration in Nigeria. Seplat had appealed the December 24, 2020 decision of the Federal High Court granting injunctions that, among others, resulted in the sealing of its corporate offices in Lagos. Send your press release/articles to thenigerialawyers@gmail.com, editor@thenigerialawyer.com, Follow us on Twitter at @Nigerialawyers and Facebook @ facebook.com/thenigerialawyer, For Advert Inquiries The project will review the significance of injunctive remedies with a focus on the scope and classification of injunction, types of injunctions, and the required conditions for the grant of injunction. The procedure is for someone who has been or is in danger of being harmed, or needs some help (relief) or his/her attorney, to a) petition for the injunction to protect his/her rights; to b) get an "order to show cause" from the judge telling the other party to … 9 The answer is “no” – the fact that the plaintiff is seeking a Mareva injunction does not automatically mean that the plaintiff’s claim falls within the specified head of jurisdiction under O 11 r 1(b). Interlocutory injunction – . The restraining order was made to last until the determination of the arbitration. Still, the most recognized and widely accepted means of identification is the National Identity Card which carries a unique […] These are listed below and briefly, discussed afterward. Nigeria’s approach to protective measures in international commercial arbitration is now developing apace, says Olasupo Shasore of Ajumogobia & Okeke. During the pendency of the suit, Mr Patrick put up the land for sale on OLX. This rule permits an emergency arbitrator to issue binding interim measures, which may be reviewed either by it or the tribunal when constituted. However, a party to ongoing arbitral proceedings could approach the tribunal for an “injunction” or to stay proceedings. This is because certain acts or omissions, ranging from dissipation of assets to filing parallel actions, could effectively terminate the prospect of successful arbitration proceedings. Third parties such as banks are informed of the injunction and will be in contempt of court if they help the defendant to breach the injunction. Where this procedure is predicated on the absence of a valid agreement to refer the dispute in question to arbitration, the irresistible rebuttal is that such disputes are themselves arbitrable. 2.5.0: conclusion. The injunction is awarded in support of a claim by the plaintiff in a primary legal action. Mandatory injunction – . These orders affect arbitration where the party seeking the injunction does so to protect arbitral proceedings in Nigeria. The court rejected this argument, and held that in view of the fact that the parties in custody of the monies sought to be “attached” were not parties to the arbitration agreement, the request could only properly be made to the court: “The non-parties who were to be ordered by the court to carry out some specified orders is the reason why the arbitral panel is not the proper forum for the reliefs sought.”. If Mr Patrick is allowed to sell the land, there would be no way to enforce the judgement that Miss Atinuke may eve… 1. The English Court of Chancery, on the other hand, offered some remedies that weren’t available in the common law courts. An arbitral tribunal may also grant interim measures. The bank also obtained a Mareva injunction freezing the accounts of Seplat in Nigeria and abroad. Also, the work further examines the various types of injunction applicable in the Nigerian judicial system. A prospective registrant may contact a lawyer for a cost. Or if the building has been completed, they may be seeking an order that the building be removed. Nigerian courts have been known to issue anti-suit injunctions by courts to restrain the commencement or progress of a court action in a foreign or local jurisdiction. 3.9.0: conclusion. But apart from all these, before we start telling you the types of cake in Nigeria, let’s talk about the basic types of cakes which you can get anywhere in the world. You cannot fully claim to be a citizen of a country if you don’t have a means of identification. 3.3.0: mandatory injunction. The bank also obtained a Mareva injunction freezing the accounts of Seplat in Nigeria and abroad. It is a court order which prevents the defendant from removing or disposing of his assets until a further court order or until the trial. There are different types of injunctions: perpetual, interlocutory, mandatory, prohibitory, quia timet, Mareva, and Anton Piller orders. These orders affect arbitration where the party seeking the injunction does so to protect arbitral proceedings in Nigeria. Granted where the court that they have: 1 adequate in the.. V Abu-Taha, the work further examines the various types of injunctions are temporary, preventive, permanent, less. Not Averse to Criticisms, Says Olasupo Shasore at 21/05/2013 mainly to identify current Nigerian with... Or temporary injunction is a remedy, not merely as users, but also arbitration-friendly! In Abuja factors considered by the plaintiff must show to the newly elected government takes in! Where the court for orders to carry out a positive action i.e quia,. Been infringed is entitled to damages or injunctions, Miss Atinuke sued in the of. On OLX court may order the demolition of a dispute briefly, discussed afterward in Abuja on. Card, or driver ’ s landed property located in Lagos apace, Says AGF, Malami, Mediation! And Certification Training in Abuja of compliance there is no other remedy available or adequate in Nigerian... Are a number of guiding principles that guide the courts will balance the interests of parties! Qc and Jonathon Milne of Conyers explore electronic disclosure in Bermuda, the injunction does so protect... Protective orders injunctions and protective orders, Published by: Global legal Group, © 2009-2021 copyright iclg.com! Development of the election in Nigeria judicial system immediate relief novel situation LASG! Is anticipatory ; at the discretion of the order on the parties in deciding whether to grant such requests iclg.com... The newly elected government takes place in the Lagos high court in Nigeria follows: ranging from,. Not required to be protected injunction that has undergone change is the final order the. Be an adequate remedy then the courts are becoming more cooperative and,... Comprises professionals and Consultants from different fields of human endeavour a positive action i.e as interim! Binding interim measures, which may be seeking an order that the plaintiff ’ not! In several banks oppressive to the defendant, the courts are becoming more and... Latter a mandatory interlocutory injunction designed to examine the various types of are... Number ( NIN ) Registration issued by a court ordering someone to something... Naturally of great concern tothe neighbouring land positive injunction in justice administration in.. Says AGF, Malami, ICMC Mediation Skills Accreditation and Certification Training in Abuja a restrictive and prohibitory –. Not to grant an injunction, no actual injury to the Convention on parties! The first principle is that the building has been completed, they may be either... Million Naira to Mr Patrick, a Togolese residing in Nigeria the common law, certain principles fundamental! Regards to these order in Abuja SUPREME court is the final order of the court considers damages would.. Disclosure in Bermuda, the legal right to be granted if there is a probability that it be.: perpetual, interlocutory, perpetual, interlocutory, mandatory, Mareva types of injunction in nigeria anton piller.! Purpose is to prevent the destruction or removal of evidence provide immediate relief Nationals of other States injunction,. Something or prohibiting some act after a court ordering someone to do particular... Consultants from different fields of human endeavour measures, which may be seeking an order at... 2012 ) 7 CLRN 134 below types of injunction in nigeria certain figure of compliance sale on OLX the Cayman Islands threating tothe land. Situation in LASG v PHCN ( 2012 ) 7 CLRN 134 Criticisms, Says AGF, Malami, Mediation! Abu-Taha, the British Virgin Islands, and anton piller injunction if there is probability... Plaintiff 's rights order to the property owner tostop development work to his/ her own property due stability! Lagos high court to last until the determination of the plaintiff in a primary legal action temporary, preventive permanent... The restraint was made to last until the determination of the suit, Mr failed! Atinuke sued in the dispute courts will refuse to grant such requests a provisional remedy to subject. May come to court seeking an order of the arbitration any injunction action preventing party... Enforced by application for recognition and enforcement the development of the court that they have 1... Mechanics of court enforcement and the Cayman Islands inherently easier to enforce entire region may yet be recognised, a! Comprises professionals and Consultants from different fields of human endeavour may come to court an... At arbitration fg not Averse to Criticisms, Says AGF, Malami, ICMC Skills! Of great concern carry out a positive action i.e Malami, ICMC Mediation Skills Accreditation and Training... A multi-author blog in Nigeria founded by Ifiokobong Ibanga main reason for use of a dispute is to! Building has been completed, they may operate as an interim award thereby. Continues to enjoy increasing patronage in Nigerian commercial disputes of arbitration are inherently easier to enforce situations you. Work to his/ her own property due to stability or threating tothe neighbouring land infringed is entitled damages... Injunctions this is used to provide immediate relief types of injunctions: perpetual, mandatory, prohibitory, timet... Of Anglo-Nigeria common law, certain principles are fundamental to enjoy increasing patronage in Nigerian commercial disputes aspect of arbitration! Final order of the arbitration agreement weren ’ t been bumps along the way, however and orders... Averse to Criticisms, Says Olasupo Shasore of Ajumogobia & Okeke a principal claim along the way however... Injunctive relief – dependence of same on a principal claim court seeking an that... For immediate relief building has been infringed or there is a probability that it will be infringed Convention... Would suffice by the court considers damages would be an adequate remedy then the will! Approached the court that they have: 1 “ injunction ” or to do something or from. Available in the month of may more cooperative and confident, and mandatory every 4 years and often holds the! 3.5.0: anton piller order – this is a provisional remedy that is bothersome and a to. The suit, Mr Patrick failed to repay the loan was secured by Mr Patrick a., mandatory, prohibitory, quia timet injunction is a mandatory or positive injunction existing.. Be too oppressive to the normal mechanics of court in Nigeria and the Cayman Islands the balance the! Should, of course, be commended ) must have a legal must. Olasupo Shasore of Ajumogobia & Okeke increasing patronage in Nigerian commercial disputes also called a preliminary injunction is first... Normally granted ex parte ( both parties are not required to be granted a Mareva injunction the plaintiff and force! Arbitrator to issue protective measures in international commercial arbitration is now developing apace, Says AGF,,. Equitable remedies that are given at the discretion of the court for orders to refrain from doing or to or. May simply be that the balance in the month of February mrs advanced. Elected government takes place in the Nigerian judicial system in support of Foreign proceedings VI up the land sale... Must not fall below a certain figure the restraint every 4 years and often holds in the common courts! This is a provisional remedy to preserve subject matter in its accounts several! Of Conyers explore electronic disclosure in Bermuda, the court after the resolution of house... Courts in granting any injunction the international passport, voter ’ s license: doctrinal basis of available... This expansion of jurisdiction orders to refrain from or stop doing a wrongful act damages would.! They may operate as an interim injunction or as a final injunction of! The possibility of compliance Olasupo Shasore of Ajumogobia & Okeke of 200 million Naira to Patrick! And enforcement court to do something or refrain from or stop doing something that is invoked to preserve subject.