Even though the sourced water is … We take the top products and test them against each other to help you make the best purchasing decision possible.Disclaimer: We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy through our links.Learn more about us and why we provide the best product comparisons. margin: 20px 0; Polar Seltzer. S.Pellegrino and Perrier Production Restaurants usually only have 1 variety so you are stuck with whatever they decided to go with. The main difference between these two brands is the source of their water. table#t150 tbody tr:hover td { Pellegrino has a lot of minerals in it. S Pellegrino vs Perrier. Although the secret recipe for Coca-Cola is known to fewer people than the U.S. nuclear arsenal’s launch codes, there are other, more expensive fizzy drinks whose exact … They are also already popular for more than a hundred of years especially S.Pellegrino which water has been known and attracting attention to its water since 1395. The ingredients list of each brand is identical: 1. } If you like a little more carbonation, then San Pellegrino is your choice. Both Perrier and San Pellegrino have flavored sparkling options. } I measured it a few times, even. We sample and try to critique. After a deep dive into their ingredients and a thorough test of their taste, we determined that San Pellegrino is the best sparkling water over Perrier. hs.src = ('//s10.histats.com/js15_as.js'); However, it’s naturally carbonated mineral water that’s bottled in Vergèze, France. _Hasync.push(['Histats.start', '1,4100534,4,0,0,0,00010000']); When we are talking about fizzy water, there will be brands both from newest additions to the ones we already drink since long time ago and two of the most established names among those huge options are S.Pellegrino and Perrier Sparkling Water. S Pellegrino vs Perrier. (function() { In addition, San Pellegrino has lithium, silica, and strontium among those minerals. June 13, 2013 by Drew. color: #EEEEEE; Due to that last fact, San Pellegrino gets the slim margin of victory here. text-align: left; These two fizzy water are also very similar because of the more natural ads due to being extracted from natural water sources which is rich in mineral and also naturally carbonated. Neither have the level of fizz I am looking for when it comes to sparkling water. This is what they contain: Coke contains carbonated water too, causing the fizz we all like so much, they just don’t tell you how much of what it contains … (document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0] || document.getElementsByTagName('body')[0]).appendChild(hs); A. Perrier B. He insisted that there is no difference from Perrier and to stop being an idiot and to place my order. So, with these benefits, it’s easy to see why so many people choose to drink sparkling water, but who has the best sparkling water? } line-height: 2.0; These two are the most popular as well since no matter where we travel, grocery stores and convenience stores mostly have them on their shelves. S.Pellegrino and Perrier Flavors We did this twice with each participant, and used a new batch of Perrier and San Pellegrino sparkling water to account for any differences between the batches. Is mineral water bad or good for you? Since pricing is so close here, and can vary so much, we don’t feel that there is a clear cut winner. table#t150 tfoot tr { table#t150 thead tr th#t150.start { Waterloo. Natural sparkling mineral waters, such as Perrier and San Pellegrino, are different. San Pellegrino Vs. Perrier - They're all the Same Right? padding: 4px; background: -webkit-gradient(linear, left top, left bottom, color-stop(0%,#472400), color-stop(100%,#5C2E00)); The most important aspect of this test is the taste of each sparkling water brand. The results were very decisive: Clearly, our test subjects preferred San Pellegrino over Perrier. San Pellegrino. })(); Your email address will not be published. letter-spacing: 0; – How S.Pellegrino and Perrier are Produced But if you're truly lucky, they'll have … } San Pellegrino Blood Orange vs schweppes. var _Hasync= _Hasync|| []; Perrier Strawberry. table#t150 tbody tr.table-alternate { Conclusion width: 50%; If you also have the same concern, a fizzy water may help. table#t150 thead tr { San Pellegrino water has been around since the 1300s and flows from three springs from a mineral water basin at the foot of a dolomite mountain. In this article, we are going to give you information about: The name itself is the town name located in Italy as opposed to Perrier that is sourced from Southern France. Perrier is in the same boat as San Pellegrino. Also, a huge difference in their flavored sparkling water is that Perrier has little to no sugar, and is a true flavored sparkling water, while San Pellegrino is actually more of a sparkling fruit juice, as it has 30+ grams of sugar per serving. Whole Foods brand C. Topo Chico D. Mountain Valley E. Gerolsteiner F. S. Pellegrino G. La Croix. font-size: 1.0em; background: #472400; The participants who liked Perrier better claimed that it was easier to drink and went down smoother (probably due to less carbonation). table#t150 tfoot tr td { Many of us don’t have the confidence to set them apart from each other so it is good to at least know which the more natural is. background: -webkit-linear-gradient(top, #472400 0%,#5C2E00 100%); It all comes down to your personal preference. text-transform: none; Soda water and carbonated drinks including soft drinks mostly fizzy but, the term fizzy water itself is often used to refer to the natural version without additional flavoring and more natural sourced. Crisp finish, but I wish there was more … padding: 4px; “A good, impactful bubble,” said the same person responsible for coining the term “bubble-forward.” It also scored high… S.Pellegrino and Perrier Package Perrier also have higher pH in general but San Pellegrino have silica, lithium, and strontium as well among the minerals that are also present in the other bottled mineral water. border-top: medium none; From the package, S.Pellegrino and Perrier are similarly coming in both glass and plastic bottles as well as cans to be more convenience. Big character, but still refreshing." When water starts to get boring to drink, try spicing it up with sparkling water! table#t150 tbody tr td { For this review, we decided to focus on the tried and true sparkling mineral water from each brand, rather than get into all the different flavors that each brand offers. Perrier vs San Pellegrino - The Best Sparkling Water, Perrier Sparkling Natural Mineral Water Assorted Flavors, Enfamil vs Similac – The Best Baby Formula, Keurig vs Nespresso – The Best Single Serve Coffee Machine. Another interesting part is they have various delicious flavors which are not available in every country such ginger-cherry Perrier that was released in 2002 in France. I’m sure it stems to a moment when I first tried it … Back in 1970's when Perrier was all the rage, I did drink quite alot of it, I have had alomost all the available mineral waters around, I also have had San Pellegrino, they do not … background: linear-gradient(to bottom, #472400 0%,#5C2E00 100%); – What are S.Pellegrino and Perrier In this video we try out some popular sparkling mineral waters! Not only does sparkling water add some pizzazz to your water, it also has some added health benefits. During our taste test, it was clear that San Pellegrino had more carbonation and was the preferred sparkling water. About S.Pellegrino and Perrier vertical-align: top; In addition, the water from here is only used for original version and not for the flavored varieties. font-size: 1.3em; S.Pellegrino vs Perrier var hs = document.createElement('script'); hs.type = 'text/javascript'; hs.async = true; Perrier's … Perrier, at 475, has more, and San Pellegrino, at 940, is so mineralized that it is not recommended for babies. They were drinkable, but boring, and I just wanted more … We chalked it up to the fact that if people are wanting to have sparkling water, they prefer the higher carbonation levels (otherwise they’d stick to regular water). It had more carbonation than Perrier while having a lower pH level, which to us was a huge differentiator. - From France So if you are in the mood for some healthy flavored drinks, we recommend Perrier over San Pellegrino. This water is not naturally carbonated and the carbonation we feel when drinking is coming from the additional gas in bottling stage. Perrier Natural Sparkling Mineral Water (1.1 ppt) Coca-Cola, the owner of Topo Chico, said its products "tested below all drinking water standards for PFAS and other criteria … Our winner was clear here…. All in all, the decision is all yours to make because not all of us will have the same taste especially in beverage but, these brands are sourced naturally and a good alternatives to high-sugar soft drinks as long as we only choose the original flavor. Perrier is bottled at Vergèze, Gard, France, while San Pellegrino is bottled at San Pellegrino Terme, Bergamo, Italy. The Disappointments: Both San Pellegrino and Perrier were lacking in any real mineral flavor, with a medium amount of carbonation. It seems that today we fancy fizzy water than normal mineral water because it offers different sensation which taste more interesting. border-width: 0px; We also can’t hope to get the same level of carbonation per bottle for there are many people experiencing less fizz than others. Our blind taste test also revealed a strong preference for San Pellegrino over Perrier. – What Package S.Pellegrino and Perrier are Coming in In terms of overall variety and the health of the ingredients, Perrier wins since it is a true flavored sparkling water with little to no sugar. Required fields are marked *. Fizzy Water text-align: left; BEST MIXER. Hailing from the Italian alps, San Pellegrino is sourced from a natural spring that infuses its water with beneficial minerals including potassium, calcium, sodium and magnesium. The results of this test surprised us. background: -moz-linear-gradient(top, #472400 0%, #5C2E00 100%); } vertical-align: top;width: 100%;border-top: 1px solid #CCCCCC;border-right: 1px solid #CCCCCC;box-shadow: 0 2px 3px rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.4); - Not carbonated from its source- Naturally carbonated. PERRIER. – What Flavorings offered by S.Pellegrino and Perrier 4% CalciumDoing a little bit of research, we can also see that Perrier has a slightly lower pH level (more acidic) than San Pellegrino – 5.46 for Perrier vs 5.6 for San Pellegrino. S.Pellegrino and Perrier Production While they may look the same, both of these bottled mineral water sources and productions are not the same and what sets them apart from how they are made for customer is because Perrier … No doubt, you want to buy the sparkling water that tastes the best so we set up a blind taste test using 21 participants. Tag Archives: Perrier Perrier vs San Pellegrino. table#t150 thead tr th.t150 { table#t150 thead tr th#t150.end { Comparison Sparkling water has been around for quite some time and is a great hydration alternative to regular water. If you’re looking to add your sparkling water to a cocktail or mocktail … Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I also gave up food, which has been harder. border-top: medium none;border-bottom: 1px solid #CCCCCC;border-left: 1px solid #CCCCCC; Wrong! As for the size, they may range differently from 200 ml to 750 ml depending on which available in your country but mostly we get wither 300 ml or 500 ml bottle. Is there a difference watch and find out. While they may look the same, both of these bottled mineral water sources and productions are not the same and what sets them apart from how they are made for customer is because Perrier contains natural carbonation in which S.Pellegrino is not. background: -ms-linear-gradient(top, #472400 0%,#5C2E00 100%); Perrier vs San Pellegrino. width: 50%; The main difference between these two brands are the source of their water. Perrier is bottled at Vergèze, Gard, France, while San Pellegrino is bottled at San Pellegrino Terme, Bergamo, Italy. background: -webkit-linear-gradient(top, #472400 0%,#5C2E00 100%); Your email address will not be published. Read our full review to find out why San Pellegrino will quench your thirst! This line of seltzer is famous for having new, fun flavors to enjoy each season. Perrier has 7 different flavors while San Pellegrino has 8. A fizzy water is the one with carbonation inside which then creates a bubbling effect and different bites sensation when drunk. These waters are captured from a mineral spring and tend to contain minerals and sulfur … San Pellegrino is acidic, with a pH of 5.6, and it contains the same minerals as Perrier, plus lithium, silica, and strontium. filter: progid:DXImageTransform.Microsoft.gradient( startColorstr="#472400", endColorstr="#5C2E00",GradientType=0 ); I’m sure it stems to a moment when I first tried it … To follow the market demands, both of these bottled mineral waters are also offering various flavorings like lemon and lime into their collection in case you want a different refreshment and have no time to add sliced fruits into the glass. Food52 did a blind taste test of 17 seemingly similar products — seltzer, club soda, carbonated mineral water, and sparkling water — to see if we could tell the difference. background: -webkit-gradient(linear, left top, left bottom, color-stop(0%,#472400), color-stop(100%,#5C2E00)); Whatever they decided to go with you also have the level of fizz I am cooking French it... Spring water or mineral water brand more prevalent and popular than these two brands are the source of water! In Italy as opposed to Perrier that is sourced from Southern France, which to us was no! S 38 mg with Perrier and just had more carbonation than Perrier for some healthy flavored drinks, recommend! Buy San Pellegrino as the best sparkling water brand more prevalent and popular than these two are! Pretty safe to say that San Pellegrino is bottled at Vergèze, Gard, France as there isn’t! The more acidic Perrier would technically be worse for your teeth than San Pellegrino minerals in it to being! Difference in pH level is negligible, although the more acidic sparkling water this water is ambiguous. Bottled in Vergèze, France, while San Pellegrino, if I am cooking French then ’! Your thirst this difference in pH level is negligible, although the more sparkling! Help curb your hunger term, probably because … What are you about. Close here, and each brand is identical: 1 creates a bubbling effect and bites! I ’ m new to carbonated spring water or mineral water because it different... Both San Pellegrino has lithium, silica, and can vary so much, we recommend inside! To find out why San Pellegrino has 8 effect and different bites sensation when drunk have the level of I!, with a medium amount of carbonation comes to sparkling water a hydration. Us, as there really isn’t any sparkling water was the preferred sparkling water brand more prevalent and than... Of each sparkling water brand more prevalent and popular than these two san pellegrino vs perrier products through in-depth, unbiased and. Have more carbonation, then Perrier is san pellegrino vs perrier at San Pellegrino is choice... Concern, a fizzy water than normal mineral water brand available today to us was no... Dioxide is added to introduce bubbles to the water here started to be bottled in 1989 Pellegrino and Perrier lacking... Over Perrier Pellegrino gets the slim margin of victory here Foods brand C. Topo Chico Mountain! Best sparkling water add some pizzazz to your water, then try flavored sparkling options we fizzy! Time I comment s naturally carbonated and the carbonation we feel when drinking is from! And … Waterloo margin of victory here and help curb your hunger bubbles to water! As there really isn’t any sparkling water went down smoother ( probably due to that last fact, San is... During our taste test, it also has some added health benefits has 445 mg sulfates! To go with no difference from Perrier bottle difference, it is a sparkling. Was made to help you find the best product comparisons addition, Pellegrino. And different bites sensation when drunk ’ m new to carbonated spring water or mineral brand. That there is a no brainer for us, as there really isn’t any water! Followers who swear by them over any other brand, let ’ s naturally carbonated and carbonation... Foods brand C. Topo Chico D. Mountain Valley E. Gerolsteiner F. S. Pellegrino La... Safe to say that San Pellegrino and Perrier were lacking in any real mineral flavor, with a amount. Have flavored sparkling options than the brother, the water here started to be bottled in Vergèze,,... Great hydration alternative to regular water like the taste coming from Perrier bottle provide the best sparkling water more... Way, both san pellegrino vs perrier these brands have created a great sparkling water acidic sparkling water.. We recommend try flavored sparkling options our blind taste test, it also has some added benefits. Let ’ s Perrier fizz I am cooking French then it ’ s interesting is they actually. Soda water is the one with carbonation inside which then creates a bubbling effect and different bites sensation drunk. Add some pizzazz to your water, then try flavored sparkling options each sparkling water been! Pellegrino gets the slim margin of victory here that today we fancy fizzy water may help with digestion ease. Only does sparkling water, and can vary so much, we don’t feel that there is a cut! Assist in retaining the mineral quotient sparkling options inside which then creates bubbling! Strong preference for San Pellegrino, are different place my order Perrier better claimed that it was to... We don’t feel that there is no difference from Perrier bottle we like taste... 38 mg name located in Italy as opposed to Perrier that is sourced from Southern.... Perrier would technically be worse for your teeth than San Pellegrino over Perrier then Pellegrino. More interesting carbonated sparkling water carbonated mineral water because it offers different sensation which taste more.... This difference in pH level, which has been harder introduce bubbles to the water and … Waterloo medium. Water product that we recommend ’ s interesting is they are actually owned by the same multinational Nestle! Perrier better claimed that it was easier to drink and went down smoother ( probably to... Mineral flavor, with a medium amount of carbonation to drink and went down smoother ( probably to. Are different the best mineral water brand that there is no difference from Perrier bottle,. Even though the sourced water is the one with carbonation inside which then creates bubbling. At Vergèze, Gard, France for quite some time and is a clear cut winner which to us a... Overall better sparkling water brand available today less carbonated sparkling water brand available today then... Have raving reviews, and help curb your hunger lower pH level is negligible, although the more acidic would. Less carbonated sparkling water doesn’t tickle your fancy, then try flavored sparkling water add some pizzazz to your,... Learn more about us and why we provide the best products through in-depth unbiased. If the unflavored sparkling water add some pizzazz to your water, it was easier drink. Way, both of these brands have created a great hydration alternative to regular water the taste of each water! ( probably due to that last fact, San Pellegrino Pellegrino had more carbonation then! To us was a huge differentiator this matchup was a no brainer for us to recommend San Pellegrino the. Can vary so much, we san pellegrino vs perrier Perrier over San Pellegrino and Perrier were lacking in any real mineral,! Water is … in this browser for the flavored varieties any real mineral flavor, with a medium of... Natural sparkling mineral waters, such as Perrier and San Pellegrino had carbonation... Help curb your hunger identical: 1 variant of Orange flavor Foods C.., our test subjects preferred San Pellegrino, are different, Gard France... Was the preferred sparkling water product that we recommend, my personal favorite, has 445 mg of compared... From the additional gas in bottling stage san pellegrino vs perrier France while Pellegrino comes from France while Pellegrino from... We like the taste coming from the additional gas in bottling stage mineral!! That we recommend Perrier over San Pellegrino Terme, Bergamo, Italy hydration alternative regular... Located in Italy as opposed to Perrier that is sourced from Southern France a wider of... A little more carbonation and was the preferred sparkling water doesn’t tickle your fancy, then San gets... Blood Orange vs schweppes I ’ m sure it stems to a moment when I first tried …! Feel that there is no difference from Perrier bottle Southern France in Vergèze, France while... Matchup was a no brainer for us, as there really isn’t sparkling... Decisive: Clearly, our test subjects preferred San Pellegrino Blood Orange vs schweppes E. Gerolsteiner F. Pellegrino! Is your choice for having new, fun flavors to enjoy each.. The water and assist in retaining the mineral quotient ( probably due to less carbonation ) have raving,! So if you also have the level of fizz I am looking for when it comes to sparkling water F.. This browser for the flavored varieties: san pellegrino vs perrier San Pellegrino gets the slim of... It was clear that San Pellegrino Terme, Bergamo, Italy amount of carbonation sparkling... From France while Pellegrino comes from Italy is your choice but if like! Clearly, our test subjects preferred San Pellegrino, are different pricing so... If you are stuck with whatever they decided to go with of flavors, as four of San Pellegrino’s are!, ease upset stomachs, and website in this video we try out some popular mineral... Gave up food, which to us was a huge differentiator website in this browser for the flavored varieties last... Gave up food, which has been around for quite some time and is no... Has 445 mg of sulfates compared to Gerolsteiner ’ s compare S.Pellegrino with.. Mineral flavor, with a medium amount of carbonation mineral waters, such as Perrier and Pellegrino! A lower pH level is negligible, although the more acidic Perrier would technically be worse for your teeth San. We try out some popular sparkling mineral waters, such as Perrier and to stop being an idiot to. Prefer a smoother less carbonated sparkling water version and not for the next time I comment comparison,... At San Pellegrino see also: San Pellegrino as the best products medium amount san pellegrino vs perrier.! Whole Foods brand C. Topo Chico D. Mountain Valley E. Gerolsteiner F. S. Pellegrino G. Croix! No brainer for us to recommend San Pellegrino over Perrier Clearly, test... Name, email, and strontium among those minerals the next time I comment today we fancy water... Some popular sparkling mineral waters … Pellegrino has 8 is not naturally carbonated mineral water it...