Head are never sequential UNLESS it tells you otherwise, and then only for the heads it directly tells you are sequential. 13:1 are described as existing after this event suggesting they are not the head that was wounded If you ask me that is a devastating wound not a healing of a wound. You can plainly see that you must go forward on the body of this beast to go forward in time. On February 10, 1798 French Republican troops under the command of General Berthier marched to Rome, proclaimed it a Roman Republic and demanded of the Pope the renunciation of his temporal power which the pope refused to concede to[18]. The deadly wound was inflicted by Napoleon’s general, Alexander Berthier. The trouble is, it is not as straightforward as it might seem at first. Thus, this creates a problem which demands a good answer. Some of the questions that I will be answering are: 1. This makes the capture of the pope on Feb. 20, 1798, totally unique and is conclusive proof that the prophecy can refer only to the event of that day. Kings 25:1-11. Retrieved on December 29, 2017 from https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/the-pope-who-outlasted-a-tyrant. At the end of the negotiations and the signing of the Lateran Concordat between the papacy and the state of Italy, the papacy had lost far more than it gained. He ruled a political kingdom. The Accomplishments of 1929 were more Wounding than Healing to the Papacy. In fact, Pius VI was able to give directives for the election of his successor. The year 1798 would present itself as the perfect candidate. That authority lasted for 1260 years until in 1798 A.D. Napoleon’s army took the sitting Pope Pius VI captive. The logical conclusion is that as a result, one cannot mark the end of the 1260 days by this means, and thereby imply that there is no way to mark it at all, so that the 1260 days obviously does not apply to them. These and many other points of views must be unlearned. Here in Revelation 5:6 & 12 we read the following about the Lamb. They see Revelation 13:10 (capture and killing by sword) as explaining Revelation 13:3 (head wound), so there is no additional information to be gained in the head wound itself since the event is explained to be a capture and killing by the sword. Of 189 guards on duty only the 42 who accompanied the pope survived. The capture and killing of the pope was a preventive against the possibility that he might attempt to violate the legal decree already in place 5 days before. In his newsletter Bacchiocchi explains what happened after the pope … The solution should be relatively straightforward. For example, on page 579 of the Old Edition she wrote: “The infliction of the deadly wound points to the abolition of the papacy in 1798.” In the New Edition however, this statement was corrected to read: “The infliction of the deadly wound points to the downfall of the papacy in 1798.“ So whereas Ellen White originally believed the events of 1798 to represent the abolition of the papacy, now she sees it as just a downfall. The reader may or may not agree with their assessment of the Bible verses and historical events in question, but the reader cannot deny that this is an effective way to argue because many will believe the arguments of the Catholic web page. The 4 heads represent the 4 kingdoms that arose out of Alexander the Great's kingdoms AFTER he died. First, you know that verse 14 says that the wound is to the beast. John, (1330-1384), called the Morning Star of the Reformation , spent most of his life teaching at Oxford University and was recognized by John of Guant (The Duke of … He chose not to. Although French Republican troops under the command of Napoleon Bonaparte invaded Italy, defeated the papal troops in 1796, when General Berthier marched to Rome on February 10, 1798 he entered it unopposed, proclaimed it a Roman Republic and demanded of the Pope the renunciation of his temporal power which the pope refused to concede to[15]. In 1798, Napoleon's army did take over Rome and the pope was taken captive to prevent an insurrection against the French authorities. In 1798, when Pope Pius VI was taken prisoner by the French General Berthier, the papacy suffered humiliation, but it would be a gross exaggeration to describe this event as the "downfall" of the papacy. Can the Bible support the claim that the Sabbath is the Seal of God? That led to all sorts of abuses, including putting people to death for their beliefs. But history has a way of being more complicated than we expect. Do not make the mistake of associating General Berthier taking the pope captive in 1798 as the wounding of the head.   This sounds straightforward enough. But, due to the events of Feb. 15, 1798, he no longer had authority over the people of God as of that exact date. 3. 3. God predicted in Revelation 13: 10 the exact manner of the papacy's deadly political wound. But in a long-awaited document on the church's role in the Holocaust, the Vatican defended Pope Pius XII, who headed the church during the war, from accusations that he … It was once more predicted that Jerusalem would fall by the sword a second time (Dan. The capture and killing of Pope Pius VI is an event that began on Feb. 20, 1798, 5 days AFTER the decree ended the Papal government. Chapter 4: Proof the Emperor Constantine did NOT give Rome to the Pope! In fact, it is interesting to note that whereas, in Revelation chapter 5 John only used the expression esphagmenon to describe the lamb, translating “having been slain”, here in chapter 13 John added a qualifier eis thanaton (to death) to the expression esphagmenon, so that it could not have been mistaken that the beast indeed had died. Pius VI resolved to go to Vienna; he left Rome on 27 Feb., 1782, and arrived in Vienna on 22 March. Gregory I (785-790) called anyone “ANTICHRIST” who took the name that Pope John Paul II took (and John XXIII took and Paul VI took!) The decree of Feb. 15, 1798, removed the Papal government. Susan Vandliver on page 21 of the book Imperial City: Rome under Napoleon informs us that “The Papal States were restored under Pope Pius VII in June 1800.[17]”. The second thing we were never told about 1929 and the so-called healing of the deadly wound is this: V. 1929 Represents a Greater Wounding Than it does a Healing. Below are illustrations that explains what is probably the most important interpretation rule of all, which the author called the Miller Principle, named after William Miller who, during 1830s and 1840s, widely taught the prophetic teachings of the book of Daniel throughout the North Eastern states in the United States. This pattern, as expressed in the rules of interpretation, can be used to help us understand the head wound, when it occurred, to whom it applied, and finally, rule out other similar events that some say could fulfill the prophecy. The question then is, how could the beast who is supposedly dead have been so active, and bold and promulgating so many significant dogmas before its deadly wound was healed? In other words, it did not take until 1929 at the signing of the Lateran concordat between Italian Prime Minister Mussolini and papal ambassador Gaspri for the papacy to recover from its setbacks of 1798. In 1793, the French held a convention in which they essentially outlawed all religion because of the abuses by the Papacy in their own history, abuses that truly had been extreme. The only decrees relevant to prophecy are those which are enforced. Note the illustration of the wound to the head (the author chose to use the neck for the location of the wound as it is easier to illustrate), which may be something like John saw. The Papal States or Temporal powers of the papacy was never restored and that came a major standoff between the Vatican and the State of Italy for almost 60 years (hence the Roman Question). So they instead of realizing that 1) 1798 was not a deadly wounding to the papacy and 2) that the 1798 event was settled two years later, they continue to look for a future healing for the 1798 events. French troops commanded by Napoleon Bonaparte defeated the … So then, according to John in Revelation chapter 13, any entity that is represented by this beast would at some point be Slain To Death with a sword. The new Pope was able to negotiate with Napoleon the Concordat in 1801 and the Organic Articles in 1802. Daniel and John were largely in the role of reporters, not interpreters, when they wrote their books (if you don't believe this, they said they wrote what they saw and John was even told once not to write something down - see Revelation 10 for details of that incident). "Power tends to Corrupt, and Absolute Power Corrupts Absolutely" [13]”,  In Ezekiel the prophecy of chapter 21 predicting the fall of Jerusalem by the sword of the Babylonians, the word “sword” is used some twenty (20) times in that chapter. In March 1799, he was living in retirement in the Carthusian Monastery at Florence…as a guest of the Tuscan Grand. 2. It is after Feb. 15, 1798, that the head wound occurs. There would indeed be more Pius' on the Papal throne during the time of the 7 heads. This means the pope was no longer able to function as head of a government that had for centuries persecuted people who worshipped God according to their conscience. The pope is the head of the Catholic Church. Growing up I gullibly accepted the narrative of 1929 and the healing of the wound without questioning its validity, partly because the argument was quite convincing. There may have been an arrest warrant, but there was no decree by the French government ordering his capture and death that the author is aware of. In the case of the leopard beast in Daniel 7, the body represented the kingdom of Alexander the Great, while afterwards, the heads represented the four kingdoms formed by his generals who divided up his kingdom among themselves after he died. Marketing your website online to generate leads & sales is crucial, and so is the customer exp… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…. Pope Pius VI asked for peace, which was granted on February 19, 1797, at Tolentino. What God counted as significant was the removal of a king, a power declared by God in Daniel 7 to be a king because he would have power over the people of God for 1260 prophetic symbolic days (which are literal years). That is to say that it would die, be destroyed, lose its life as a result of the wound of the sword – however, the death blow would be healed and the beast would live again. [14] Destruction of The First Temple by Berel Wein adapted by Yaakov Astor. My quick…, Gael Sorry for the late response but thank you for your encouragement.…. [4] Matthew E. Bunson in his article The Pope Who Outlasted a Tyrant, Catholic Answers. Let us go back at the text one more time before we delve in: 1And I stood upon the sand of the sea, and saw a beast rise up out of the sea, having seven heads and ten horns, and upon his horns ten crowns, and upon his heads the name of blasphemy. Among the many features that John saw and shares with his readers – seven heads, ten horns, ten crowns, names of blasphemy, mouth of a lion, feet of a bear, features of a leopard, the prophet also saw that this beast had received a mortal wounding to one of its heads, the which was also healed. This event is referred to, in Bible prophecy, as the time when one of the beast's heads was wounded (Revelation 13:3). 13 because the wound is described as healed (in the past) The 7 heads of Rev. Were the requirements of Revelation 13 with respect to the beast satisfied by the treatments of the Pope and the Papacy by the French in 1798? It says that it is a wound by the sword to the beast (verse 14). That is why it is called “mortal” suggesting that the individual who has been wounded in such a manner cannot live. This period ended in 1798 when General Berthier of Napoleon’s army conquered the various Italian states, and eventually took the reigning pope, Pius VI, prisoner to northern Italy and then back to southern France, where he died in August 1799. When Pius VI left Rome on February 20, 1798, he was an old, dying man who still functioned as Pope, though in a limited scale. Click here to read their web page about this if you didn't click on it above (Please read it, for it is interesting). Why was there a need for the 1929 Concordat? The body represents the 1260 year power of the Papacy. To effectively answer their challenge, one needs to find a way of conclusively proving the 1798 capture is the only one that can apply. Now that we have the end date of 1798, all that would be left to do is to count backward 1260 years to find the starting date, thus you arrive at the year 538 AD. But the deadly wound to papal influence during the reign of Pius VI was not to be a fatal wound: Pius.  John uses this exact expression (esphagmenon) earlier in chapter 5 to described the Lamb who appeared in the vision of the throne room and whom we know to be representing Jesus. This web page is written to document what has been found and to show what the author believes is an effective, conclusive way to deal with the issues raised on the Catholic web page. Rev. On 29 August 1799, the leader of that corrupt religious system, Pope Pius VI died a … The Bulwark article entitled Pope Pius the XI reports the following glaring and most daring statement that a pope could ever make, especially at a time when it should have been wounded to death: “On April 29, 1922, in the Vatican throne room, a throng of cardinals, bishops, priests, nuns, boys and girls, who had all fallen on their knees in reverence of the one before them, were then addressed from the throne by Pope Pius XI, who said: “you know that I am the Holy Father, the representative of God on the earth, the Vicar of Christ, which means I am God on the earth.[20]”. 180 International is to inspire a Spiritual Awakening among Youth and Young Adults. Papal Rome from deadly wound in 1798 A. D. until Recovery, 7. So then, the question is, how then did advocates of the theory of the beast representing Roman Catholicism arrive at the 538 starting date and the 1798 ending date? During the French revolution, Napoleon Bonaparte invaded Italy in 1796 and occupied Ancona and Loreto. This implies that only the capture and killing AFTER Feb. 15, 1798, has any connection with the head wound. ⁣In 1798, French troops entered Rome and imprisoned Pope Pius VI. Even pro-Imperial cardinals had to pay to save their properties from the rampaging soldiers.” The Roman Curia online described the savagery and massacre thus, “Across the Sisto bridge the lansquenets and Spaniards fell on the city and for eight days committed every sort of violence, theft, sacrilege and massacre, even the tombs of the Popes, including that of Julius II, were violated in search of spoils. Can the Bible Support the claim that Sunday Worship enforced, or the National Sunday Law is the Mark of the Beast? And contrary to the common teaching regarding this beast, when the forty-two months are expired, there would be no resurgence of this beast power. Number 1) it lost forever its temporal power as the papal states were never restored, 2) the pope had to renounced its claims over most of the city of Rome and all temporal claims and 3) all that it was left with was a sovereign state confined to a small 109 acre property within the city of Rome called the Vatican City. It alone is the only event that can fulfill the prophecy. The confiscation of the States of the Church on September 20, 1870, and the confining of the Pope inside the Vatican for the next 59 years, represents in my view a more significant (head wound – Rev 13:3) blow to the papacy than the temporary imprisonment of Pius VI in 1798 which lasted only few months.” The temporary humiliation, or deadly wound as it has been called, of 1798 did not last for over 131 years as it has been traditionally taught. Disturbing Facts We Were Never Told About The 42 Months And The Ten Horns. Rome was proclaimed a republic and the pope died the next year in exile. Evidently, neither was the case in 1798 – the pope was not slain by the sword of the French emperor Napoleon’s nor was the Vatican City destroyed. Thanks to the Jesuits. …The crowning event of Pius IX’s pontificate was the convening of the First Vatican Council on December 8, 1869. Now, the beast is quite well known to be the church-state combination that existed during the dark ages. That is to say that everything this beast would do from the moment it rises up and begins to act (its blasphemies, its persecution of the saints, its dominion over every nation, tongues and people) until its final demise and removal from the scene would be contained within a 42-month time frame. Under the authority granted him by the Eastern Roman Emperor, Justinian, which became effective in March of 538 AD, he had authority to punish whatever he decided was heresy and to be the head bishop over all Christian bishops. But it is a false claim. Those heads it is silent about will always be concurrent. Verse 10 mentions that a man who takes captive must be taken captive, and he who kills with the sword must also be killed with the sword. “When, in 1797, Pope Pius VI fell grievously ill, Napoleon gave orders that in the event of his death // --> The author sees good reason to believe that their argument will be looked upon favorably by many. Ryan. At one blow Assyria disappeared from history. The corrected reading of the New Edition is a noticeable improvement, but it is still inaccurate. (Which is why it is odd that a Jesuit was elected Pope in the 20th century). 31:8 makes the following prediction: “Then shall the Assyrian fall with the sword, not of a mighty man; and the sword, not of a mean man, shall devour him: but he shall flee from the sword, and his young men shall be discomfited.”, This prophecy was fulfilled with precise accuracy. So, heads always come AFTER the body. Other dogmas that were also promulgated by the papacy during the time when the beast was supposedly dead or wounded mortally included: The dogma of the Immaculate Conception that the Virgin Mary was free from the original sin by virtue of the merits of her son Jesus Christ – In 1854 by Pope Pius IX. Remember that the wound was supposedly healed in 1929. This answers the question of what was accomplished by his capture and death in prison. You won't find it! Since verse 10 is stated in the context of the discussion of the beast and the subject matter has not changed in verse 10 (it changes in verse 11), this strongly implies that the man who does these things, is in fact connected to the beast and is the one most responsible for it's actions - the pope. "He Who Does Not Remember History Is Condemned To Repeat It" It was pillaged and burned, and then razed to the ground so completely as to evidence the implacable hatred enkindled in the minds of subject nations by the fierce and cruel Assyrian government.” (Lenormant and E. Chevallier, The Rise and Fall of Assyria). He was taken captive for the simple reason that it was feared he might cause an insurrection against the French authorities if allowed to remain free in Rome. Pope Pius VI (born Count Giovanni Angelo Braschi, 25 December 1717 – 29 August 1799) was head of the Roman Catholic Church and ruler of the Papal States from 15 February 1775 to his death in 1799.. Pius VI condemned the French Revolution and the suppression of the Gallican Church that resulted from it. I would like you to observe that both the dogma of the Papal Infallibility (1870) and the claim of Pope Pius XI of being god on earth (1922), were done during a period of time when the deadly wound of the Papacy was still not yet healed. John Damascene+ Antiquarianism, condemned by Pope Pius VI in Auctorem Fidei, (DZ 1533) originated at the Jansenistic Council of Pistoia in the 1700s.